September 17, 2009

What Does War Cost?

author_janis By Janis Prince Inniss

(Spoiler alert: In this post, I describe important plot lines of the movie In the Valley of Elah as well as some grisly details of a homicide.)

Recently, I saw the film In the Valley of Elah. Starring Tommy Lee Jones, the film tells the story of a retired Vietnam veteran named Hank (Jones) who is informed that his son Mike is absent without leave (AWOL) having just returned from a deployment to Iraq. Finding this to be out of character for his son, Hank quickly heads from his home in Tennessee to his son’s base in New Mexico to investigate. Because he was a military police officer, Hank spots a number of holes in the stories he is told about his son who has apparently vanished.

When police find Mike’s body dismembered and burned in a field, there is the usual silence and stonewalling from various military officials . How did this happen? Who would have done such a thing? Was Mike a drug dealer? What might Mike have been involved with that might explain his death? What happened to him in Iraq? Hank finds Mike’s cell phone and with the help of a technician is able to look at some of the video on the phone. The videos on the phone are jarring to say the least but they provide a lens by which Hank—and movie goers—see some of the grim reality that Mike experienced before his death.

Hank realizes that Mike’s buddies in his military unit are lying about their last night together, but Hank knows that this does not suggest their guilt because soldiers do not kill each other. Or do they? The truth is that Mike’s comrades murdered him and then lied about that night, the night after they all returned from Iraq.

Initially, I was surprised to learn that this film was based on the real life murder of Army veteran Specialist Richard T. Davis in 2003. As in the movie, Davis was reported AWOL to his retired veteran father who then investigated his son’s disappearance. One night after returning from Iraq, Davis and some other soldiers went out; they drank and fought and one of the soldiers stabbed Davis (Alberto Martinez) at least 33 times. The soldiers then bought lighter fluid, returned to the crime scene, lit Davis’ body on fire and then buried it in the woods.
Watch CBS Videos Online


How is this possible? Why would soldiers “on the same team” commit such a heinous act on one of their own? Martinez’s defense lawyer says the solider was delusional at the time of the killing. Another is said to have been experiencing post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) during this time. Recent research on the issue indicates that 37% of veterans from Iraq and Afghanistan who have sought care at VA medical centers were diagnosed with mental health problems—primarily PTSD and depression and another 10% have alcohol and drug use disorders. A RAND study of veterans found that 14 percent screened positive for PTSD and the same number screened positive for depression, rates higher than found in the general U.S. population (3.5% and 7.0% respectively). Further, RAND extrapolates that if these rates hold for all military deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan , 300,000 people are experiencing depression and PTSD.

As alarming are the numbers of suicides by U.S. soldiers which have skyrocketed since the start of the Iraq war to more than 2,100 attempts in 2007 compared to 350 in 2002, the year before the war began. The New York Daily News headline “More soldiers committed suicide in January than killed by Al Qaeda” highlights the fact that the suicide rate in the Army is the highest it has been in 30 years—143 in 2008. The other leading concerns discussed—PTSD, depression, and drug use—might both be related to these suicides as returning soldiers find their relationships unraveling as they struggle with untreated, maybe undiagnosed mental health problems. They turn to drugs and alcohol for comfort and some finally commit suicide. (Thirty-one year old veteran Josh Barber’s suicide illustrates some of these complex relationships among these factors.)

You may recall that I was initially surprised to learn that In the Valley of Elah was based on a real homicide. Although I found the answer to the “whodunit” in the movie shocking and continue to be distressed by the crime, as a mental health professional and sociologist I have often worried and wondered about the impact of war on soldiers. (This is distinct from issues related to the impact of war on civilians in war-torn countries.) How do soldiers train for and act on that training to destroy others but reintegrate into a peaceful society? What do we owe veterans as they grapple with these experiences? Are these questions related to ideology? In other words, are those “for” either war more or less concerned with these questions than those “against” them?

Surely you’ve heard various dollar figure costs of the war in Iraq and the one in Afghanistan. But what about the psychological toll experienced by soldiers? How do we measure those costs? What other psychological and sociological costs do you think wars create?

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83534ac5b69e20120a5bae63d970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What Does War Cost?:

Comments

I read you above post and came up with the conclusion that war and young people do not mix. Young kids are going into the army and going crazy. They get to the point where they just want to kill someone and by the time it is all said and done they end up hurting themselves or killing themselves.

I read your post and I definatly agree with you. War has a major effect on our soldiers that will stay with them the rest of the lives. Many of the soldiers may always be violent because of what they learned in the military. PTSD is a serious medical issue that many people have no idea that they have. It doesn't suprise me that soldiers killed a fellow soldier after a night of drinking and a small fight. Being overseas is a stressful situation and violence is all you come to know. I wasn't surprised that the comrads would strike out with violence rather than use their words when they had just come from a hostile situation where killing was normal.

I think that the country has to implant an efficient system that would follow soldiers coming back from war. Not only economically but also psychologically. Doctors should identify fragile characters and help them to recover. Any human being will be affected by such experiences. It is our duty to support the soldiers that defend the country by putting their lifes on the line.

Why is the 3 trillion dollar cost Iraq War under reported?
In doing an internet search on the actual cost of the Iraq war, I have found that the vast majority of estimates available still give estimates of 500-800 billion. However, it is common knowledge that responsible accounting practices for legitimate companies must include "known future obligations" when disclosing cost estimates. Why do so few Iraq war cost estimates fail to include even conservative projected costs for replacement of worn equipment and long term care

Will Liberals who inflate the cost of the Iraq War use the same math on the stimulus cost?
If I believe the website that counts the war cost and I'm generous (on the high side) we'll say it's at $600Bn. I've seen people go unchallenged saying the cost is anywhere from $3Tr to $5Tr so I'll again be generous (on the low side) and say $3Tr. That gets us a multiplier of 5. We'll call it the Liberal Math Multiplier. So saying the stimulus package is $800Bn, shouldn't they be claiming the real cost is 4 trillion dollars?

I agree with your opinons. War would cost a lot of money and not only that but also lives. I think that the costs of war are more than just what we pay out of our pockets but also we pay with the lives of our people.

It is terrible how psychologically damaged soldiers can become while going to war. It is insane to think that soldiers would violently murder someone from their own side. It is also surprising how many suicides there are of people surviving in the army, and even more alarming that the rate is drastically increasing. I also question how soliders can go from being trained killers to being peaceful citizens after they return home. War is terrible.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Become a Fan

The Society Pages Community Blogs

Interested in Submitting a Guest Post?

If you're a sociology instructor or student and would like us to consider your guest post for everydaysociologyblog.com please .

Norton Sociology Books

You May Ask Yourself

Learn More

Essentials of Sociology

Learn More

The Real World

Learn More

Introduction to Sociology

Learn More

The Everyday Sociology Reader

Learn More

« Suburbanizing Rural America | Main | The Wages of War: The Oldest Profession »