Getting a Job: Weak Social Ties and On-Line Connections

By Bradley Wright

Last summer my wife was looking for a summer job, and she did the usual things—read the employment bulletins and sent out applications. Ultimately, though, she got a job through an acquaintance. We see this person a few times a year, and she heads up an administrative unit here on campus. My wife applied, got the job, and we all lived happily after.

This story illustrates the somewhat cynical mantra of all job seekers that it’s not what you know but who you know. Sociologists call this phenomenon the strength of weak ties.

A “weak” social tie, in every day language, is an acquaintanceship—someone with whom you are familiar with but not too close. In contrast, a “strong” tie would be a good friend or close family member, someone with whom you interact a lot. An “absent” tie would be someone who you know but don’t really have any kind of relationship with.

In a famous sociological study, Mark Granovetter interviewed several hundred business people and asked them how they got their jobs. Seventeen percent reported learning about their jobs from a close friend (strong tie), 28% reported learning about it from someone they barely knew (absent tie), and a full 56% of the respondents reported learning about it from an acquaintance (weak tie).

It’s a bit of a paradox: Why are acquaintances, people we sort of know, more important in the job search process than our close friends and family? Our strong ties, after all, care about us more and would be much more willing to help us.

The answer, according to Granovetter, is that weak ties are a unique social resource: they connect us with a wider set of social networks than do social ties. Your acquaintances each have their own strong ties—family and friends to whom they are very close to. Through your acquaintances, you gain access to their strong ties—and to the social networks to which they belong. All social networks offer various resources, such as information about job opportunities, and so by connecting with a greater number of social networks, via weak social ties, you gain access to more possible employment opportunities. 

Strong ties, in contrast, connect us with fewer social networks. Your best friend in the world would probably do anything for you, but chances are that the two of you know many of the same people. As such, it’s not that your close friends and family don’t want to help you in a job search; it’s just that they have less to offer because you probably already know about most of the contacts that they would offer. You already share many of the same networks with them. So, there’s a trade-off. Strong ties are more willing and available to offer help, but weak ties typically have more resources to offer.

In this context, it’s interesting to think about the many social ties created by the Internet. About a year ago, I started blogging, and through that I have had contact with dozens, if not hundreds, of people with similar personal and research interests as mine. Likewise, most college students have Facebook accounts in order to keep track of their friends and make friends with their friends’ friends (got that?). As a result of this on-line networking, this generation may have more casual social ties than any before.

The question, then, becomes the nature of these online ties. Granovetter studied fairly conventional acquaintances—people you see in person at places like the work place or social gatherings. Online acquaintances are different. If I met some of the people I know from online, I don’t think that I would even recognize them. Yes, we’ve exchanged many comments on our blogs, and I know a fair amount of information about them, how they think, what they do, but I’ve never met them in person.

Would these on-line ties be as useful in a job search? The answer is… I don’t know. The focus of these on-line relationships is social networking, getting to know each other pretty much for the sake of getting to know each other. The interactions with these people tend to be more social—what you’re doing, what interests you share in common. I’m not sure how often instrumental concerns come up. In everyday conversation, it’s easy to drop in the information that you’re looking for a job, but it might fit in more awkwardly in online interactions.

Perhaps more importantly, though, is that the social networks and resources offered by online connections are often too distant to be of much value. For example, one of the people I interact with online lives in Kenya. Now, he may know of great job opportunities for me, and be very willing to help, but unless I’m willing to relocate to Africa they don’t do me much good. This maybe why in-person acquaintances remain so important—by virtue of meeting them face-to-face, you occupy the same physical location, at least briefly. Chances are, therefore, that the social resources they have to offer would also be close and thus of greater value.

So, do you want to get a job? Make sure to let your acquaintances know since they may be very helpful. Your online connections might be as well, but probably not as much.

Comments

[Mike]

On the use of social sites like Facebook, I think like all technology, it really depends on how individuals use it. In a recent apartment search I had all but given up on finding a place. I posted a note to Facebook including only people in my geographic region. Within a week, through a friend of a friend, I had located a place.
Although these social sites provide you with a wider net to gather resources, it's still largely dependent on where you choose to deploy it. While my friends and acquaintances abroad couldn't help me with this task they could offer ideas and advice on other topics. Perhaps the class conflict of the future will be between those who fully utilize technology and those who don't.

[Tabitha Freytag]

This topic has become of growing importance to me. I have set my career aside and gone back to school to pursue a degree in sociology (but of course). For me, the question becomes, how would I jump back into the job market after school? Keeping in contact with the people whom I know from my past seems to be to my advantage. The on-line approach has seemed to be one option of keeping in touch with people whom I rarely talk to but have enjoyed professional relationships with.

I notice more and more the commercial emphasis on “social networking”. Whether it is LinkedIn, Facebook, professional Blogs, or on-line job services there seems to be a huge focus and let’s not forget money making opportunity for some with on-line “social networking”. I have started a LinkedIn account in hopes of keeping in contact with my past business contacts and keep this “social networking” working for me. In the past I have used an on-line professional service from whom I still get regular emails reminding me how important it is to keep growing my social network as I look for a new job before I need one.

I can tell you this: it is exhausting! I seemed to have picked up a new part-time job expanding my “social network” and thinking about how to keep in contact with people. Now that I have read this blog article it gets me to thinking about how one can never replace the face-to-face contact with people. It will be interesting to see what sociologist have to say about the impact and dynamics all this “social networking” creates in peoples daily lives, personal, and professional relationships.